本帖最後由 kwongyauleung 於 2010/7/10 19:50 編輯
Very nice video but it is about health and scientific medicine. people feel alternative medicine might be useful and can solve their problem and pain. 有d人覺得某d方法有效.但係有無科學根據的.
==
If you feel something exist, and yet there is no way you can demonstrate to anyone that it does, is it not an delusion? Or rather, how do YOU differetiate your experience from a delusion?
How do you differentiate wishful thinking from reality? How do you differentiate the TV set with little green man and the TV set that the engineer designed?
How do you decide if you buy the TV set or not?
--> 其實係唔可以的. 我認為宗教性/神性,係好個人既體驗. 所以其實我唔可以話你知的. 因為我唔係傳教. 你有就有,無就無.
If you cannot define God, how is it different from ADFR, or grable --> 對. 你可以咁講的.. 你無體驗,就係無. 某人信主,因為上次佢求主俾佢合格,最後佢合格左, 咁佢就信了. 呢個係佢既體驗,佢覺得好神奇, 但其他人說無根據. 但他信了. 因為佢太想合格了.. 佢之前一晚有祈禱. 佢覺得係神聽了佢的話. .. 你如何講科學也沒有用.
我唔係話佢既經驗係假, 亦唔係話神係真係聽到佢講.
因為神本身係無定義的.. 應該話無統一定義, 例如"即食面"呢樣野有統一定義 但神就有很多... 例如... 有求必應, 全能萬能,造物者,.. 審判者..
你看..只是各取所需吧...
my definition of god is "whole of existence". 對於我就係. 但係對於你可能唔係的.
你要看清有兩個方向... 其中一個,就係分辨, 用懷疑做論點做起點. 呢個就係科學. 以唔信開始先.
而另一個,就係合一,整合. 就係宗教性/神性既方向.
在科學既方向,你所有野都要先懷疑. 有論據,再求證找真相.
但另一方向. 係信任. 所以宗教都係要你信左先. 咩教你都係要信左先.就會知道佢地所講既野係唔係真. arm 唔 arm 你.
有很多野無一定解釋的.. 都很個人需要的.. 宗教如是, 找伴侶如事. 用科學係解釋唔到的. |